Blof-fan wrote:Ghehehe I don't mind a good rant
Thanks for sharing the Ogura info. I really dind't think those units would reach 63%

And I was impressed with those TVS's, that's why I looked into them. But the shear size of those things kind of put me off...
Comparing Turbo's and Superchargers is like comparing apples and eggs in this discussion
It's really not though. You are talking about ways of making pressure over atmospheric.
If option A will make 20 PSI boost at 300f and one will make the same pressure at 400f it's worth mention. The latter won't make nearly as much power and will be much more detonation prone. Fortunately we have intercoolers that brings that overall temp down a lot but how low still depends on the air going in.
So effeciency will always be high since you will always get more out if it than you put in
We are not even getting into the amount of energy required to drive the compressor. And yes a turbo does take power from the engine to run it. It's not nearly as easy to calculate how much though.
We are just talking about outlet temps and their effect on performance. Now yes if we look at the big picture Adiabatic efficiency will tell us a lot about how much energy is going into compressing air and how much energy is going into creating heat but to break it down we are largely concerned with what the outlet temp is coming from the compressor.
I would be very happy if I get 200hp from my GZE. And I would probably be able to do that with my SC12 too. But I have never read anywhere about anybody bolting a TS on a GZE and the charastristic of the TS just appeals to me, so why not try it
Have you ever driven a turbo 4AGE with a turbo sized for 200 HP? It would spool about as quick and in a very similar fashion to a SC anywhere over 3k RPM. You step on the gas and go. Even my DSM T25 which can easily make 250 WHP spools almost instantly over 3500 RPM.
[img]And%20I%20would%20probably%20be%20able%20to%20do%20that%20with%20my%20SC12%20too.%20But%20I%20have%20never%20read%20anywhere%20about%20anybody%20bolting%20a%20TS%20on%20a%20GZE%20and%20the%20charastristic%20of%20the%20TS%20just%20appeals%20to%20me,%20so%20why%20not%20try%20it[/img]
Then all the power to you. Just don't get upset when someone puts half as much money into a turbo setup that will walk all over your car in the straights and in the corners.
That's my main issue with the twinscrew or other new off the shelf SC systems. It sounds like you can do all the work yourself and I still bet you spend over $3k US.
Now I don't mean to sound like I am bashing your idea. I am very interested to hear how it turns out.
Half my point is that I really feel like 80% of the people who "don't like turbo characteristics" haven't driven a properly setup small turbo car. You get all these kids throwing a 500 HP capable CX racing turbo on their car and running 5 PSI boost and they get walked on by just about anything and need to wait till noon just to spool the thing.
That said however I am very interested to see the results and hope you at least push this thing a little bit because I want to see what a TS can really do on a 4AGE.
You can find some threads by mr2swift on the mr2OC about the TS kit he has had in development for like 10 years now. You might find some interesting info in there but take it with a grain of salt as he doesn't understand much about tuning, fabricating design or compressor theory. I think he has gotten about 250 WHP out of a TS though.
Have I already mentioned that I want to incorporate a Water to Air intercooler into the new intake manifold?
Nope but have you met my car?

If I ever do get around to doing a TS kit I would love to offer an intake mani with an integrated IC.