"He also said with a goal of 160-180 HP.
I would love to see your plans for a 170 HP carbed 4AGE along with a rough guess on the price it would cost to get it there. "
I never said he could get everything he wanted. And to even talk about a "carbed 4AGE" is ridiculous, once you put carbs on that block, you effectively have a 4AC no matter what the pieces came from.
"So you are saying he should run EFI but also carry carbs as a backup? "
Rhetorical question?
"How does a knife not running out of bullets apply to the point you are trying to prove? Carbs are not infallable and have many issues of their own so I don't see it being in any way applicable. "
Knives, like carbs, are relaitvely simple. Once you move to EFI, or even a half-assed throttle body EFI like we have instead of real cylinder injection, life gets complicated. Injectors, computers, matching ignition electronics, fuel system complications, and of course the AFM/MAF and more associated wiring, the fuel cut-off relay and dual timing signals for starting versus running...
No, carbs aren't infallible and even in street use they should be rebuilt maybe every 5 years. The difference is, you can pull four bolts, take the carb off to a tabletop, do a total rebuild and pretty much anyone with good hand skills can do that in one afternoon.
Diagnosing and repairing an entire EFI system? As the official facgtory pros said, maybe an hour, maybe a day. Or two. Carb just needs one master rebuild kit and a gallon of gumout.
"Simpler in a way perhaps however in his case that does involve ..."
Doesn't matter what you and I think is simpler, HE asked about ripping it out and going with carbs. To some folks, electronics and computers are a great scary mystery and they want no part of it. I don't question that choice. Apparently you do.
"This page should at least allow him to roughly figure out what ECU he has. Judging by the yellow clips I am going to say a standard 9.4:1 NA 4AGE ECU found in Corollas and MR2s.
http://www.diyautotune.com/diypnp/models.html "
"if he plans to run boost...it's presumptuous of you to assume anything of the sort. "
On the contrary, I haven't made any assumptions, I've just replied to his question. And since he hasn't mentioned boost, I'm not assuming anything about it. What do they say in the army? "Don't ask don't tell". No one mentioned boost.
"going 4AC would be taking four steps backward and putting quad carbs on it would be like taking half a step forward."
Yeah, but following Bill Sherwood's web site would pretty much give him the instructions for best bang for the buck right away. Except, so many folks think they can find a magic way to reinvent a better solution. Sometimes, someone does, but the options and limits to an AE8x with any period engine have pretty much been worked out long ago.
Like a 1950's Chinese restaurant menu, you take one from Column A, one from Column B, end of story. Price, performance, pick from each and that's that.
"I would recomend he find out which bottom end and pistons he has in there which it sounds like he plans to do."
Sure, but if I was starting with a box of parts and I wanted a 50% hp increase...first I'd find a good machine shop, order up some good parts instead of assuming the replaceable ones had never been stressed, and plan to have it blueprinted, ported, polished, CC'ed. And if it had a stock bluetop compression, fix that too.
"Any mechanic who is confused about a switch from AFM to MAP should be permanently benched and ship me all of their tools. "
Heheh. So the genuine factory authorized trained dealership mechanic who did my thousand-mile courtesy check and couldn't find the idle screw...Who sadly is or was typical of factory trained mechanics...
"Manuals are readily available online if you know who to ask or where to find them."
Oh, now you expect them to be able to READ as well?
"Quite possibly but don't forget about needing to adjust the points regularly."
On what planet? First time I adjusted points was on my '68 Mustang. Which sometimes got care at one of the leading Ford dealerships in the country. The mechanic asks me how I set the gap and I said I used a feeler gauge and he almost fell over in shock, I was within 1/2 degree of dead on. No great skill there, and never found it off much on regular tuneups.
"Also don't forget the power that this technology has gained us." Right, the way the new cars typically have a hundred sensors and ten more to tell you which ones have failed and all sorts of good stuff that gets nasty expensive to fix.
"Plus I hate fking with points." Most mechanics have callouses too thick to allow them to play the violin, cracking safes, or adjust points. Yes, I'm happy not to have to adjust them or file them, but really? Is it any worse than gapping and changing spark plugs used to be?
If we haven't totally lost the OP by now...he wants to do what he wants to do, whatever that is. Let him have fun doing it, his way. No matter what you do to a GT-S...a Nissan GTR can still get you locked up faster and longer.<VBG>
Column A, riceburner. Column B, "Officer, I'm on a donut run. Would you like to drive?"