Inconsistent Charging.
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2015 3:25 pm
Alright.
So over the last 5 months or so...or whenever 86fest was(alternator died on arrival) I've been having alternator problems...well actually after 86fest there wasnt any problems until a few weeks ago when my alternator died(alt that I replaced at 86fest with a refurb from pepboys)
I was driving to get dinner on a friday night noticed my digi dash started to flicker and fade. my lights began to dim yada yada I'm sure you know how it goes. so I ended up getting home with the help of a friend giving me a could charges(luckily I have a nice yellow top optima battery which made it possible to get home 35ish miles on a 30 min charge)
Got it home tested it alternator wasnt charging. so got another from pepboys. did some research and decided to go with a 91 corolla gts with 4ag alternator since its outputs a bit more amps...(70amps over our normal 60.) figured it wouldnt be a problem with it being the same engine should be able to handle the revs and what not. first one was bad.. caused a lot of popping thru my speakers and I could literally hear the alternator turning when I was looking at it in the engine bay. which isnt something I've ever been able to hear it sounded unbalanced. it also didnt keep a consistent voltage so I called PB and ordered a replacement. went to go pick it up smartass kid that worked there was like "that just sounds just like a grounding problem but okay I need to test it anyways company policy" yada yada just based off the fact that there was popping thru my speakers(which could be correct if the rest of the problems werent present) well he was wrong and wouldnt even show me the test results because they were bad obviously. then he proceeded to tell me they didnt have my replacement I ordered I told him to go check the will call he did and WOW my alternator was there.
okay I'm going to stop with my rage story and get to the point.
new alternator got it. dropped it in. worked fine in the garage tested at about 14.2v at a 900rpm idle. then while driving charge light came on.(sometimes it will even turn off for a while then come back on) got it home it read 12v and was slowly dropping at first. now heres what weird. if I let it just run. it will slowly climb in volts. up to about 12.7-13v depending on the day. sometime it will work fine for a while then randomly the charge light will pop on. I've also noticed that it will happen after I down shift sometimes (may be unrelated but worth a mention) also if I rev it up real quick while idling it will go up to about 13.4 vand then if I give it a few more revs it will drop back down to >12v then slowly climb back up. it is just another bad alternator I checked all the wires and ground locations I know of and can see in the charging circuit itself. all seem good and connected. no blown fuses or anything. I have about .4 ohm in the positive cable coming from the alternator to the battery. I'm pretty stumped as of right now other then getting another alternator and hoping its actually a good one I dont know what else to do the cable to the positive post on the alt is starting to look pretty ugly. so maybe I should replace that one? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
any input would be greatly appreciated.
thanks guys
So over the last 5 months or so...or whenever 86fest was(alternator died on arrival) I've been having alternator problems...well actually after 86fest there wasnt any problems until a few weeks ago when my alternator died(alt that I replaced at 86fest with a refurb from pepboys)
I was driving to get dinner on a friday night noticed my digi dash started to flicker and fade. my lights began to dim yada yada I'm sure you know how it goes. so I ended up getting home with the help of a friend giving me a could charges(luckily I have a nice yellow top optima battery which made it possible to get home 35ish miles on a 30 min charge)
Got it home tested it alternator wasnt charging. so got another from pepboys. did some research and decided to go with a 91 corolla gts with 4ag alternator since its outputs a bit more amps...(70amps over our normal 60.) figured it wouldnt be a problem with it being the same engine should be able to handle the revs and what not. first one was bad.. caused a lot of popping thru my speakers and I could literally hear the alternator turning when I was looking at it in the engine bay. which isnt something I've ever been able to hear it sounded unbalanced. it also didnt keep a consistent voltage so I called PB and ordered a replacement. went to go pick it up smartass kid that worked there was like "that just sounds just like a grounding problem but okay I need to test it anyways company policy" yada yada just based off the fact that there was popping thru my speakers(which could be correct if the rest of the problems werent present) well he was wrong and wouldnt even show me the test results because they were bad obviously. then he proceeded to tell me they didnt have my replacement I ordered I told him to go check the will call he did and WOW my alternator was there.
okay I'm going to stop with my rage story and get to the point.
new alternator got it. dropped it in. worked fine in the garage tested at about 14.2v at a 900rpm idle. then while driving charge light came on.(sometimes it will even turn off for a while then come back on) got it home it read 12v and was slowly dropping at first. now heres what weird. if I let it just run. it will slowly climb in volts. up to about 12.7-13v depending on the day. sometime it will work fine for a while then randomly the charge light will pop on. I've also noticed that it will happen after I down shift sometimes (may be unrelated but worth a mention) also if I rev it up real quick while idling it will go up to about 13.4 vand then if I give it a few more revs it will drop back down to >12v then slowly climb back up. it is just another bad alternator I checked all the wires and ground locations I know of and can see in the charging circuit itself. all seem good and connected. no blown fuses or anything. I have about .4 ohm in the positive cable coming from the alternator to the battery. I'm pretty stumped as of right now other then getting another alternator and hoping its actually a good one I dont know what else to do the cable to the positive post on the alt is starting to look pretty ugly. so maybe I should replace that one? ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
any input would be greatly appreciated.
thanks guys